Who'd have thought that deciding to give somebody a little leeway and choice in a gift you buy for them could cause so many heated feelings! Gift certificates and gift cards have been around for quite a long time now, and every year they are worth billions to retailers worldwide, forwomen's gifts, men's gifts and kids' gifts alike. And while they can be a godsend to gift givers, some recipients are actually angered by them! Today we check out the debate in terms of women's gifts about whether to send a gift certificate or an actual gift.

Gift certificates - Benefits and drawbacks
Gift certificates are seen by some people to be impersonal, not well thought out and even an imposition on free will. Others simply enjoy getting a gift, and like the idea that somebody at least tried to personalize the item.
Benefits of gift cards and gift certificates:
- If you aren’t sure what somebody would like as a gift, it helps personalize it a little
- They can be used at any time
- They offer choice!
Drawbacks of gift cards and gift certificates:
- Often your recipient will have to put in some extra money in order to get what they really want - the gift card amount will seldom match their purchase exactly!
- Otherwise, the retailer gets 'free money' out of you - an unused amount left sitting on the gift card until it expires
- People may not like anything from your chosen store, and may prefer cash
Real gifts - Benefits and drawbacks
Real gifts are much more personal ... but much more hit and miss! Remember that you can always ask your recipient exactly what type of gift they'd like, or throw out a few ideas and let them pick the one they like best without giving too much away ... this overcomes many of the difficulties of real gifts.
Real gifts are much more personal ... but much more hit and miss! Remember that you can always ask your recipient exactly what type of gift they'd like, or throw out a few ideas and let them pick the one they like best without giving too much away ... this overcomes many of the difficulties of real gifts.
Benefits of real gifts:
- When you hit the nail on the head with your gift (like a delicious body lotion or gorgeous piece of jewelry), your recipient will remember it forever
- Some people feel that they show more thought and effort
Drawbacks of real gifts:
- If you buy a real gift that your loved one doesn’t like or can’t use, they'll feel bad also ... not your aim!
It's a very personal decision whether to give gift cards or real gifts ... our personal leaning is towards asking what somebody would like, or giving them the choice of a few 'categories' of gift ... and then just buying the real one! Surprise only lasts for a little while ... but the gift is there forever.

